Best Air Fryer Toaster Ovens 2020 Consumer Reports

Air fryer toaster ovens have been a trend for quite a while now. A scrumptious combination of crispiness on the outside and juiciness inside is what an air fryer toaster oven is best at. As it cooks with zero oil, this interesting kitchen appliance gives you all the goodness without the guilty feeling. So if you are looking for the best air fryer toaster ovens to settle down with your buying decision, this buying guide is right up your alley. 

Air fryer toaster ovens have evolved so much recently. It’s thus important to take a closer look at their features to find a perfect match for your personal preferences. Let’s now dig right in!

Top 10 Best Air Fryer Toaster Ovens 2020 Reviews

1. Cuisinart TOA-60 Air Fryer Toaster Oven – Best Reputable Brand

When it comes to kitchen appliance manufacturing, Cuisinart has no longer been a strange name. If you already have something “Cuisinart” in your kitchen, the buying decision should be easy.

Cuisinart has claimed its trustworthy quality for decades. Even though it’s not boasting about the all-in-one cooking functions, all of its settings (air fry, convection broil, broil, convection bake, bake, reheat, and toast) are high-performance. 

All control knobs are also highly adjustable. There should not be any difficulty in getting used to its settings and mechanism. There’s nothing lagging behind, so if you are looking for a reliable machine, this is it. 

Its reliable performance comes with a comprehensive package – air fryer rack/basket, baking pan, and oven rack. It’s basically everything you need to start with an air fryer toaster oven and have a mouth-watering typical French-style breakfast in a blink of an eye. 

However, beware of the setting knobs; they start to lose the timing accuracy over time. On top of that, they’re not so easy to clean. You will need to spend quite some time removing the stubborn dirt around the edges. 

Pros

  • Long-lasting brand name
  • Reliable 7 cooking functions
  • Comprehensive package
  • Highly adjustable setting knobs

Cons

  • Control knobs lose accuracy over time
  • Not easy to clean around the knobs

2. COSORI CO130-AO 12-in-1 Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo – Best Versatile Air Fryer Toaster Oven

COSORI CO130-AO 12-in-1 is an air fryer toaster oven with “a bit of everything.” Versatile and flexible, those are the two keywords for this oven. 

Among 12 functions, there are some advanced ones you probably enjoy – Dehydrate, Bagel, Rotisserie, and Ferment. And the best part is, as it is also an air fryer, you’ll get all the healthy properties from the foods.

Now, if you are wondering whether it can really do the job as it does many jobs – most all-in-one products never actually excel at anything – then here is a piece of good news. Its performance is not compromised by the versatility. The design comes with an interior light, and there are up to five heating elements. You can thus easily check on your dish to see if it’s ready. And expected wellness is always even on every spot of the food surface. 

Cleaning this thing, however, can be quite a labour, especially when you cook something with fat in it (bacon, burger, steak, etc.). The grease coming off from the food can be a mess inside. And if you let it build-up, the machine will make a rattling noise while running. 

Pros

  • 12-in-1 cooking presets
  • Well designed interior light 
  • Five heating elements
  • Consistent food quality

Cons

  • Not easy to clean
  • Can be noisy sometimes

3. Ninja Foodi Digital Air Fryer Toaster Oven – Best Cooking Capacity

Ninja Foodi Digital Air Fryer Toaster Oven is one of the best toaster ovens with smart design. With ist XL cooking capacity, you have a large and flat surface area for your dish. 

The best selling point of Ninja Foodi Digital Air Fryer Toaster Oven is that it lets you reclaim your counter space in a flash. Specifically, you can flip it up to store after you’ve done using it. If you don’t want your toaster oven to take up valuable space on the kitchen counter, Ninja Foodi should be your choice.

As the design of Ninja Foodi Digital offers a spacious cooking area, the machine allows for faster cooking speed. The air roast circulates inside in a well-arranged pattern, saving your time for both preheating and cooking. Breakfast for not only yourself but also your entire family can be served in a matter of minutes, and so you will not find it a headache to get to work in time while maintaining a hearty eating habit!

A drawback of this air fryer toaster oven is that the timer does not have any break after the preheat. You may need to add 1 minute to put the food in. The rack system also cannot accommodate items that are too big. It has a large surface, but the height is quite a limit. 

Pros

  • Large usable pan cooking area
  • Flip-up to store
  • Fast cooking with air roast
  • Space-saving on the counter

Cons

  • The cooking timer starts counting right after preheat is done
  • A limit of height in the rack system

4. Instant Omni Plus Air Fryer Toaster Oven – Best Easy-to-Use Dials

Instant Omni Plus Air Fryer Toaster Oven is a wise choice for those in search of an easy-to-use kitchen appliance. All dials and function buttons are adjustable. The LCD display is accurate and responsive, making it quick and easy to cook with just a touch of a button. 

The digital readout is also easy to follow, and the automatic programs go smoothly. They help you to keep track of the cooking progress and be ready right when the food is done. 

Aside from the ease of use, this air fry toaster oven keeps things minimal; still, the safety feature is worth an applause. It never gets dangerously hot and can burn one’s hand upon contact, even when you’ve been using it for a long time. As trivial a feature as it might look like, having it around certainly brings about massive benefits should you have limited space for a kitchen and all the vital utensils gather at one spot only.

A downside of its design is that the power cord is quite short; you will need to place it near the electricity source. The basket is also not big enough for big size servings. You will find yourself repeatedly cooking new batches when preparing for a party. 

Pros

  • Cook with the touch of a button
  • Easy-to-adjust dials and function buttons
  • Digital readout is easy to follow.
  • Good safety features

Cons

  • The basket is not ideal for party size servings.
  • The power cord is quite short.

5. Instant Vortex Plus Air Fryer Oven 7 in 1 – Best Minimal Design

The design of Instant Vortex Plus is minimal and efficient. You can fit both cooking trays at once, saving your time to cook different dishes in a meal.

And thanks to its sleek construction, the cleanup and maintenance won’t be much of a challenge. Drip pan, rotisserie basket and spit, cooking trays, and forks are all dishwasher-safe. Cleaning this oven after making your toast is just a breeze. 

The optimal look is not everything. Instant Vortex Plus Air Fryer Oven 7 in 1 is also a helpful cooking assistant that can take care of all your cooking demands, starting from the common ones like baking or frying to something on a more sophisticated level like dehydrate and rotisserie. Plus, once cooking with it, you get to address the problem of excessive oil. With the One-step EvenCrisp TechnologyTM and a sleek design, this air fryer toaster oven reduces the grease to the lowest level possible. 

A disadvantage of this oven is that it gives out a smell like burning plastic during its operation, especially in the first use. The top tray also takes up more heat than the bottom one. You’d better arrange your food with the required heat accordingly. 

Pros

  • One-step EvenCrisp TechnologyTM
  • Sleek surface for minimal grease
  • Ability to fit both cooking trays at once
  • Ease of cleanup

Cons

  • The smell like burning plastic
  • The bottom tray does not cook as well as the top

6. Kalorik AFO 46045 SS 26 QT Digital Maxx Air Fryer Toaster Oven – Best French Door System

Kalorik AFO 46045 SS 26 QT Digital Maxx looks quite different from an ordinary air fryer toaster oven. It has two front doors opening to the two sides of the machine. This design allows for more space inside the oven. Aside from just your breakfast toast, a whole chicken or a full 12-inch pizza won’t cause any difficulty for the machine. 

The modern French door system also facilitates the airflow. And with a maximum temperature of up to 500 Fahrenheit degrees, It cooks 30% faster than leading air fryer ovens and 50% faster than most conventional ovens. 

Another good thing is, the “exotic” design of the Kalorik AFO 46045 SS 26 QT Digital Maxx does not compromise the ease of use. There is also a manual showing you simple steps for use and cleanup. You will soon get to make the most out of the cooking device in no time!

Note that there can be some smoke coming out the first time you use it, so don’t panic. Regarding the crispy quality, don’t expect too much; this air fryer toaster oven does not rank among the top ones. 

Pros

  • Modern French Door System
  • Large family size
  • Turbo MAXX airflow system
  • Simple and easy to follow instructions

Cons

  • Can release some smoke at first use
  • Medium crispy texture

7. Black+Decker TO3265XSSD Extra Wide Crisp ‘N Bake Air Fry Toaster Oven – Best Countertop Baking Oven

Black+Decker TO3265XSSD Extra Wide does best with baking recipes. With superior bake function and XL capacity, both reheating leftovers and baking new things are done efficiently. 

If you think baking is complicated, it’s now time to think again. It’s fair to say that this air fryer toaster oven is highly newbie-friendly. Black+Decker TO3265XSSD Extra Wide has only three control knobs to adjust the preset. You will soon “feel the beat” once you try making toast with the machine. 

Another advantage of baking with this air fryer toaster oven is that it does not make much noise while running. And the noise is still kept low even after a long time using it. If you are never fond of the idea of getting your quiet breakfast interrupted by all the machinery rumbling, this will do the job nicely!

A downside of Black+Decker TO3265XSSD Extra Wide is that the air frying function on this oven is quite weak. And there are some user reports claiming there is no instruction coming with the machine. However, this is just a minor inconvenience as the Black+Decker doesn’t involve a steep learning curve.  

Pros

  • Bake function and extra-wide capacity
  • Bake and reheat with ease
  • Simple three control knobs
  • Quiet fan

Cons

  • May not come with cooking instruction
  • Air frying is quite weak

8. CalmDo Air Fryer Oven Combo – Best Accessories

Among all air fryer toaster ovens mentioned in this list, CalmDo Air Fryer Oven Combo is the one with the richest accessories. And when we are saying “richest,” we mean it in both quantity and quality.

Right from the box, you will have ten different accessories – a rotisserie rod, tong, cage, and stand, a drip tray, an oven rack, a mesh basket, a skewer rotisserie, and two mesh trays. Enough to serve a whole party on Thanksgiving, much less yourself only!

Many accessories also means many preset functions. In that manner, you can let your cooking soul be free and do whatever you want with this air fryer toaster oven, from saute and roast to rotisserie and dehydrate. 

Another valuable accessory of the CalmDo Air Fryer Oven Combo is the splatter guard attached inside the machine. It helps reduce the grease sticking on the interior of the oven, and thus cleaning will never be one heck of a struggle. 

A disadvantage of this air fryer toaster oven is the Rotisserie function. Beware of the heat while using it. And if you are going to make Rotisserie chicken, a big turkey poultry may not fit inside. 

Pros

  • Rich accessories
  • All accessories are easy to clean
  • 18 one-touch preset functions
  • Splatter guard to reduce cooking mess

Cons

  • Rotisserie clip not safe
  • Limited space for Rotisserie chicken

9. CROWNFUL 9-in-1 Air Fryer Toaster Oven – Best Digital Touch Screen

CROWNFUL 9-in-1 deserves to be one of the most advanced air fryer toaster ovens on today’s market. Its high-tech digital touch screen control panel has everything you need to start cooking right away. 

With this control panel, it’s easy to see the cooking time, temperature, and other controls designed to cook different dishes. On top of that, it is packed with Auto shut off and overheat protection features, ensuring safety every time you cook.

There is also a light control on the screen, giving you a clear look at what is inside and how well done it is. The touch screen’s design is completely separate from the door. You can remove the door for cleanup and attach it again with ease. 

Two missing things on the CROWNFUL 9-in-1 Air Fryer Toaster Oven are the wire pan/ basket and cookbook. Consider if it’s a big deal before settling down with your buying decision. 

Pros

  • Easy-to-operate digital touch screen control panel
  • Auto shutoff & Overheat protection
  • Light control
  • Detachable door

Cons

  • No wire pan/basket
  • No cookbook

10. Aobosi Air Fryer Toaster Oven – Best 2 Speeds Convection Oven

While other air fryer toaster ovens seem to focus their effort on improving the cooking capacity and settings, Aobosi Air Fryer Toaster Oven chooses to upgrade its cooking speed setting. It is one of a few that comes with two cooking speed options. 

This upgrade allows for more air circulation, giving more heat inside the machine while still distributing it evenly all over the food. Combined with the ability to rotate food inside the oven, Aobosi ensures there is no “burnt outside, raw inside” scenario. 

As you sometimes want to cook at a certain convection speed, Aobosi designs a door that can be pulled down at four levels. The design allows you to give a certain amount of natural outside air to the food when necessary. 

However, the door may get loose over time; it pulls down completely and cannot hold itself at the minimum level. Another note worth noticing is that the actual cooking time can be shorter than that mentioned in the instructions. You may need to adjust it depending on different cooking situations. 

Pros

  • Two optional levels of convection speeds
  • Ability to rotate the food inside the oven
  • fast and even heat distribution
  • 4-level pull-down door

Cons

  • The actual required cooking time is shorter than that mentioned in the instruction.
  • The door gets loose over time.

Air Fryer Toaster Ovens Buying Guide

Choosing the best air fryer toaster oven from the list of 10 options can be a daunting task. It’s thus crucial to walk through a buying guide to facilitate your buying decision. 

Size

Your air fryer toaster oven should fit your available kitchen counter space. It’s a good idea to measure the ledge before considering the oven’s size. Besides the width and height, it’s also important to consider its weight. Especially if you are going to move it around frequently, you may not enjoy having an enormous and heavy-weight gadget. 

Capacity 

Air fryer toaster ovens come in many capacity options. Depending on how big you want your servings to be or how often you use the oven, the capacity needs to come into play. 

However, beware that big capacity normally means big size. Medium ovens range from 0.6 – 0,8 cubic feet; bigger ones come in 1.0 – 1.2 cubic feet. 

Performance

There can be many preset temp settings; still, what really matters how well the oven can maintain the heat at its set level. A fluctuating temperature is the last thing you want, as it brings an unevenly cooked meal. Some other features to look at when judging its performance are internal fans, speed, and noise. 

Safety features

When it comes to choosing an appliance involving the use of heat, safety is always one of the priorities. And air fryer toaster ovens are not an exception. Automatic shutoff, durable material, and exterior shield are some features in need to make sure the gadget is safe to use. 

Interface

Some people like it to be advanced; some others prefer it to be minimal. Each air fryer toast oven may have its own design. Look at its settings and how they are laid out on the oven. Do they match your preference? At the end of the day, it’s ideal to have an oven that helps you with your cooking without breaking a sweat. 

Functions

An air fryer toast oven can play many roles – reheating, searing, roasting, baking, broiling, etc. Are you looking for a specialty or a versatile machine? Also, if you want more advanced functions such as drying or slow cooking, be ready for a higher price. 

Price range

A reliable air fryer toaster oven doesn’t come with a surprisingly low price. Normally, the product quality aligns with how much you are willing to spend. 

You will find more advanced ovens around the high-end price spectrum. Such things as LCD display, accessories, and top quality materials could be a strike to your budget. 

Accessories

Some people may say they are just a marketing gimmick, but if you have the right type of accessories, they’re really a valuable add-on. Suitable accessories make you enjoy the gadget even more. They further improve the performance and versatility of the product. 

Air Fryer vs. Toaster Oven

If you are hanging between the two options and asking, “Which one is better?” that’s perfectly normal. Most buyers have the same options when they have to make a decision. Let’s go through this detailed comparison and find out the answer. 

What is an air fryer & What is a toaster oven?

An air fryer uses very little or even no oil to cook fried dishes. The appliance uses convection air currents to heat up the food. With the ability to circulate hot air at a very high speed, air fryers can deliver the crisp perfection while still ensuring the meals’ healthy properties. 

A toaster oven is basically a more compact version of a conventional oven. Its front door is either downwards or sideways, depending on its design. Toaster ovens are also highly versatile; you can use it to toast, broil, bake, etc. 

Heating

In an air fryer, the heat comes from the coils, which is promoted by a powerful fan. The heating elements are usually placed on one side of the appliance and generate convection air currents.

In a toaster oven, the heating elements radiate to warm up the air inside. These heating elements are the strips at the top and bottom of the oven. In other words, the main heat source comes from its baking pan. 

Cooking Method

An ordinary toaster oven includes a few cooking methods. When considering the flexibility, an air fryer has the edge over a toaster oven. It can even dehydrate and air fry – functions that you won’t find on most standard toaster ovens. 

Cooking Capacity

Air fryers are generally smaller than toaster ovens. Most air fryers can cook for 2-3 servings. So if you are looking for a machine with a bigger cooking space, the price would be much higher. 

Cooking Speed

An air fryer makes food faster most of the time, as it has a powerful fan to circulate the hot air inside. However, as the name implies, a toaster oven is faster at toasting. If you have some slices of bread that need warming up, a toaster oven will do a better job. 

Cleanup 

Air fryers offer more advantages regarding the ease of cleanup and maintenance. And as air fryers come in smaller sizes, they take less of your time and effort to clean. With that being said, most toaster ovens these days come with non-stick materials, making it easier to give it a fresh look after use. 

FAQs

1. Why should I buy an air fryer toaster oven?

The biggest plus of having an air fryer toaster oven is that you can enjoy the benefits of two kitchen appliances in a single one. To be more specific, an air fryer toaster oven is more space-saving, versatile, and economical. 

You won’t have to pay for two machines and place them at two different places on your kitchen countertop. Still, you can cook healthy dishes with a minimum amount of oil. With the combination of hot air circulation, airtight seal, and powerful fan, an air fryer toaster oven reduces the wait during your cooking time. 

2. What can you do with an air fryer toaster oven?

An air fryer toaster oven has quite a lot of space to spread food, so you can cook many things with it. Some common uses are drying fruits, making toasts, baking pizza, etc. 

3. Which are some best brands for air fryer toaster ovens?

Among countless brands out there on the market, some safe-to-trust brands are Cuisinart, Black+Decker, COSORI, and Ninja Foodi. 

4. Are air fryer toaster ovens bad for you?

There’s no reason to consider a toaster oven as a health hazard. It just uses regular heat to cook your food, which is completely different from the microwave. There thus should be no worries at all. 

5. Can I put aluminum foil in an air fryer toaster oven?

Yes, but it should be when you reheat/ warm-up something. For actual cooking at a high temperature, it’s not recommended to use foil in it. 

6. How can I clean a dirty air fryer toaster oven?

If the self-cleaning mode cannot satisfy you, soak the accessories overnight in warm water mixed with dish soap or baking soda. Scrub them gently and rinse again with clean water. Let them dry completely before reassembling them to the machine. 

7. Do things cook faster in an air fryer toaster oven than in a microwave?

When it comes to actual cooking, the answer is yes. It’s because the air fryer toaster oven is better at applying heat and circulating the hot air. 

The Bottom Line 

Our buying guide and detailed review on the best air fryer toaster ovens have just come to an end. Generally, it’s safe to say that having an air fryer toaster oven is a blessing. 

Choosing a perfect match for your cooking preference requires elaborate research on the expected specs and features. Scrutinize your needs, have some serious reading about the best options, narrow down your choices, and your air fryer toaster oven should be right around the corner.